I hear this all the time: “Can you add something to collect email addresses?” or “Can you add something where people can sign up for my newsletter?” My answer? A resounding YES! But here’s the thing: it’s not just about plopping a sign-up box on your website and calling it good. The real magic lies in creating something irresistible so that your audience can’t help but type in their email because you want to be able to grow your email list from your website!
An email list is more than just a collection of addresses. It’s your golden ticket to connect directly with your audience, bypassing social media algorithms and putting your message right in their inbox. Ready to grow yours? Let’s dive into how to grow your email list from your website!
Why Your Website is the Perfect Place to Grow Your List
Your website is your home base—the one place online where you have total control. No shifting algorithms, no competing for attention with parenting videos (though I do love finding some good activity ideas). It’s a space to showcase your voice, brand, and expertise.
Think of it this way: your website is like the front porch of your home. It’s inviting, approachable, and designed to make people feel welcome. Adding ways to grow your email list is like setting out a plate of fresh-baked chocolate chip cookies (or your favorite treat)—it’s an irresistible invitation to stick around and get to know you better.
Have I convinced you yet?
5 Key Ways to Encourage Sign-Ups on Your Website
1. Add a Lead Magnet (aka Something Valuable for Free!)
People love free stuff—especially when it’s valuable, relevant, and genuinely useful.
So, what’s a lead magnet exactly? It’s a freebie like a checklist, template, or mini-guide that solves a specific problem for your audience. For example, I created the Must-Have Elements for a High-Converting Homepage to help business owners tackle the overwhelm of designing or refreshing their homepage. It’s specific, helpful, and exactly what they need. It’s been one of my favorite ways to connect with new people—it feels like sharing a little gift every time someone signs up.
The key to a great lead magnet? Make it relevant, actionable, and easy to use. When someone downloads it, they should feel like you’ve read their mind and handed them exactly what they needed!
2. Keep Your Sign-Up Form Front and Center
Visibility is everything. Make sure your sign-up form is easy to spot—whether it’s in your hero section, sidebar, footer, or even as a subtle pop-up. The key is to find a balance between noticeable and not annoying. There’s a fine line between being helpful and being that person who waves frantically from across the room!
The right placement can make all the difference. Here are some high-visibility spots to consider: • Your website’s hero section (that’s the very top, where you make your first impression). • A sticky header or footer that follows users as they scroll. • Your blog sidebar or at the end of each post. • A well-timed pop-up that appears when visitors have spent some time exploring.
3. Use Actionable Copy
Ditch the generic “Sign up for updates” because honestly, that’s about as exciting as cold toast. Go for something that sparks curiosity and action and makes people say, “Yes, I need this in my life!” in order to grow your email list from your website. Here are a few things you could try:
• “Get weekly tips to simplify your business!”
• “Unlock exclusive resources to elevate your brand!”
Actionable copy makes it clear what people are signing up for and why it’s worth their while. You know your audience best so tailor the language to match their needs and your brand voice.
4. Showcase Social Proof
People want to know they’re not alone in signing up. If you have an engaged audience or rave reviews, share it! Social proof taps into that feeling and builds trust by showing that others are already benefiting from your content.
If you have a growing list, mention it. Try something like:
• “Join 500+ creatives growing their businesses with my actionable tips and inspiration!”
Not there yet? No problem. Share testimonials, highlight wins from people who’ve used your lead magnet, or even celebrate your first sign-ups with excitement.
5. Make It Mobile-Friendly
More than half of website traffic comes from mobile devices, so make sure your sign-up forms are optimized for smaller screens. There’s nothing worse than trying to pinch-zoom your way through a tiny form on a screen. A quick test on your phone—or better yet, a friend’s phone—can save you from losing potential subscribers to frustrating formatting.
Overcoming the “What Do I Say?” Hurdle
One of the biggest roadblocks is the fear of not knowing what to say in your emails. Maybe you’re worried about sounding spammy or running out of ideas. I’ve been there, and let me tell you—it’s easier than you think.
Here’s the secret: consistency beats perfection. Your emails don’t have to be perfect. They just have to be you. Share a tip, a personal story, a resource that inspired you, or even a curated list of your favorite resources. Here’s the thing: your audience doesn’t expect perfection. They just want to hear from you. Be real — that’s what matters most.
Tip: Share a story of something that happened to you and relate it to your business/target audience. For me it would be a coffee shop that didn’t have space to work and relating it to how important user experience for your website is.
How to Grow Your Email List From Your Website Today
Ready to grow your email list? Start with these three steps:
- Decide on Your Lead Magnet.
Think about what your audience needs most. A checklist, mini-guide, or template can be a game-changer.
- Choose a User-Friendly Email Marketing Platform.
Here are a few I’ve used and would recommend:
Flodesk: Known for its beautiful, user-friendly templates and simplicity makes your emails feel like a breath of fresh air.
ActiveCampaign: Perfect for advanced automations and segmenting your list as you grow.
Mailchimp: A solid choice for beginners with a free plan to get you started.
My tip when choosing a platform? Think about where you’d like your list to be in a year or two because you don’t want to be migrating to a new platform every couple years. Trust me.
- Add a Clear, Visible Sign-Up Form to Your Site.
Make it easy for visitors to subscribe. tart with one well-placed form,test your form to ensure it works seamlessly, and you’re good to go! If you’re waiting for the “perfect” time to start, this is it. You can tweak things as you go. You don’t need to have everything figured out—just take the first step, and the rest will follow.
Your Email List Journey Starts Now!
Your email list is more than just a collection of names. And it’s more than just a marketing tool. It’s a community of people who believe in what you do. And your website? It’s the bridge that connects you to them. With the right tools and strategies, growing your email list from your website doesn’t have to feel overwhelming. So, what are you waiting for? Let’s make it happen! If you’re ready to add an email sign-up to your website but aren’t sure where to start, drop me a message. I’d love to help you bring your vision to life!
Save this to Pinterest for later!
